Jenny’s Goods
Order Now

Place your order

Everything is baked to order by Jenny. Pick the option that fits what you need.

Order from the menu

Cookies by the dozen, cupcakes, pies, brownies, cinnamon rolls, holiday trays and kits. Set prices: choose your items and a pickup date and time, then pay online.

Shop the Menu

Custom cakes, cupcakes & cookies

Birthday, wedding and tiered cakes, themed and filled cupcakes, decorated cookies and personalized sets.

Tell us your idea and add inspiration photos or Pinterest and Instagram links. Jenny will call you with a price, then email an invoice to pay online.

Start a Custom Request
  • Please order at least 5 days ahead.
  • Free pickup in New Castle, the Boardman, Ohio area or Cranberry, or delivery to your door (free within 10 miles of a pickup spot).
  • Catering or charcuterie? Call or text Jenny at 724-498-8494.
Need it sooner? Call or text 724-498-8494

Common Questions

Questions People Ask

Why don’t custom orders show a price?

Every custom cake, cupcake and cookie order is different, so Jenny calls you first, then quotes and sends an invoice.

How much notice does Jenny need?

Five days for every order, online or custom. Need it sooner? Call or text 724-498-8494 and Jenny will tell you what’s possible.

From Jenny’s Kitchen

Get the Holiday Menu First

Seasonal menus, order-by dates and new flavors, a few times a year. Nothing else.

Unsubscribe anytime. Jenny never shares your email.

© 2026 Jenny’s Goods · New Castle, PA · Privacy Policy · Terms and Conditions

Food Allergy & Safety Notice

Jenny’s Goods takes great care in preparing our baked goods, catering selections, and charcuterie offerings. However, our products are prepared in environments where common food allergens may be present.

Products may contain or come into contact with milk, eggs, wheat, peanuts, tree nuts, soy, sesame, fish, shellfish, and other allergens.

Because ingredients, equipment, utensils, and preparation areas may be shared, Jenny’s Goods cannot guarantee that any product is completely free from allergens or allergen cross-contact.

Gluten-Free & Dairy-Free Options Available

Jenny’s Goods offers select gluten-free and dairy-free options upon request. However, these items may be prepared in shared environments and are not guaranteed to be free from allergen cross-contact.

Customers with food allergies, sensitivities, or dietary restrictions should inform Jenny’s Goods before placing an order. Customers with severe or life-threatening food allergies should carefully consider whether products prepared in a shared environment are appropriate for them.

By purchasing or consuming products from Jenny’s Goods, customers acknowledge the potential risks associated with food allergies and sensitivities and are responsible for making purchasing and consumption decisions based on their individual dietary needs.

Nothing in this notice is intended to waive or limit any rights or responsibilities that cannot legally be waived under applicable law.