What We Offer · Custom Cakes and Baking

Something Extraordinary to Share

Looking for custom cakes? New Castle, PA is home, with free pickup near Cranberry Township, PA and Boardman, Ohio too. Baking here is about creating something memorable, with quality ingredients, careful attention to detail and a passion for exceptional flavor.

Free pickup in New Castle, the Boardman, Ohio area or Cranberry. Delivery free within 10 miles.

Custom cakes New Castle, PA: buttercream cake covered in sugar butterflies

Creations

Cakes, Cookies, Cupcakes and Pastries

Winnie-the-Pooh baby shower cake: “You are loved more than you will ever know”

Custom cakes designed around your celebration.

Pink baby shower cookies: bows, onesies and hearts

Cookie Creations

Handcrafted cookies for gifts, parties and events.

Vegan, dairy-free chocolate peanut butter cupcakes

Cupcake Creations

Cupcakes made to match your theme.

Dessert tower with chocolate mousse cups, macarons and cannoli

Pastry Creations

Pastries and confections not found in the traditional bakeshop.

Request a Quote

Holiday Confections

Pies for the Holiday Table

  • Dark Cherry Pie
  • Dutch Apple Pie
  • Maple Bourbon Pecan Pie
  • Pumpkin Pie

Food Allergies or Dietary Restrictions?

Please let us know about any food allergies, sensitivities or dietary restrictions when placing your order. Gluten-free and dairy-free options are available upon request.

Please review the Food Allergy & Safety Notice for important allergen and cross-contact information. The FDA also explains the major food allergens.

If You Can Imagine It, Let’s Create It.

Tell Jenny the date and the occasion. She’ll call to hear your inspiration.

Common Questions

Custom Cakes, New Castle, PA: Questions People Ask

Can Jenny’s Goods create a custom cake design?

Yes. For custom cakes, New Castle, PA is home base, and Jenny designs each one around your celebration, theme and guest count. If you can imagine it, she will help create it.

What baked goods can I order from Jenny’s Goods?

Cakes, cookies, cupcakes, pastries and seasonal holiday confections like pies, cinnamon rolls and browned butter sea salt brownies.

How do I share food allergies with my order?

List every allergy, sensitivity or dietary restriction in your order form so Jenny can plan your baked goods with care.

Does Jenny make custom cakes for the Pittsburgh area?

Yes. Custom cakes and custom cookies are baked in New Castle, with free pickup in Cranberry for Wexford and the Pittsburgh area. Searching for custom cakes Pittsburgh families can pick up nearby? Choose the Cranberry spot when you order.

Order Now

Two Ways to Order

Order from the menu and pay online, or send a custom request and Jenny will call you with a price. Everything needs 5 days’ notice.

Order From the Menu

Cookies, cupcakes, pies, rolls, brownies, trays and kits. Pick a time and pay online.

Custom Cakes, Cupcakes and Cookies

Share your idea and inspiration photos. Jenny calls, quotes and emails your invoice.

From Jenny’s Kitchen

Get the Holiday Menu First

Seasonal menus, order-by dates and new flavors, a few times a year. Nothing else.

Unsubscribe anytime. Jenny never shares your email.

Food Allergy & Safety Notice

Jenny’s Goods takes great care in preparing our baked goods, catering selections, and charcuterie offerings. However, our products are prepared in environments where common food allergens may be present.

Products may contain or come into contact with milk, eggs, wheat, peanuts, tree nuts, soy, sesame, fish, shellfish, and other allergens.

Because ingredients, equipment, utensils, and preparation areas may be shared, Jenny’s Goods cannot guarantee that any product is completely free from allergens or allergen cross-contact.

Gluten-Free & Dairy-Free Options Available

Jenny’s Goods offers select gluten-free and dairy-free options upon request. However, these items may be prepared in shared environments and are not guaranteed to be free from allergen cross-contact.

Customers with food allergies, sensitivities, or dietary restrictions should inform Jenny’s Goods before placing an order. Customers with severe or life-threatening food allergies should carefully consider whether products prepared in a shared environment are appropriate for them.

By purchasing or consuming products from Jenny’s Goods, customers acknowledge the potential risks associated with food allergies and sensitivities and are responsible for making purchasing and consumption decisions based on their individual dietary needs.

Nothing in this notice is intended to waive or limit any rights or responsibilities that cannot legally be waived under applicable law.