Jenny’s Goods
Order Now

Custom Orders

Custom Cakes, Cupcakes, Cookies, Catering and Charcuterie

Cakes, cupcakes, cookies, catering and charcuterie: every custom order starts on this one form. Placing a custom cake order? New Castle, PA, Cranberry Township and Boardman, Ohio customers are in the right place. Tell Jenny your idea, add your inspiration photos and pick a date. She calls you, prices it with today’s costs and emails an invoice you pay online.

Start Your Custom Order
Rather talk? Call or text 724-498-8494
Custom cake order, New Castle, PA: painted birthday cake for Michaela
Winnie the Pooh baby shower cookies

Before You Start

Why Every Custom Order Gets a Quote

Why do custom orders need a quote?

Fondant and modeling chocolate prices can jump by twenty dollars from one week to the next, and catering and charcuterie depend on your menu and guest count. So Jenny prices every custom order herself, from a custom cake order (New Castle, PA, Cranberry and Boardman customers alike) to a full catering spread, and you get today’s price. See her past work on Instagram.

How far ahead should I order?

Give Jenny at least 5 days. Decorated cookies take around three days to make, and 5 days keeps your order from being rushed. For catering, send your date as early as you can: Jenny takes one catering event a week.

Your name
For your request copy and invoice.
Jenny will call you at this number.
What are we making?
Choose all that apply.
Drag & Drop Files, Choose Files to Upload You can upload up to 5 files.
Up to 5 photos, 10 MB each: phone photos, screenshots, or pictures saved from Pinterest or Instagram.
How do you want to get it?

Date and time
Everything is baked to order: at least 5 days from today.

Need it sooner? Call or text 724-498-8494
Dietary needs
Food allergy notice

Custom orders are priced personally. Send your request and Jenny will call you to go over the details and your price, then email you an invoice to pay online.

Stay in touch

From Jenny’s Kitchen

Get the Holiday Menu First

Seasonal menus, order-by dates and new flavors, a few times a year. Nothing else.

Unsubscribe anytime. Jenny never shares your email.

© 2026 Jenny’s Goods · New Castle, PA · Privacy Policy · Terms and Conditions

Food Allergy & Safety Notice

Jenny’s Goods takes great care in preparing our baked goods, catering selections, and charcuterie offerings. However, our products are prepared in environments where common food allergens may be present.

Products may contain or come into contact with milk, eggs, wheat, peanuts, tree nuts, soy, sesame, fish, shellfish, and other allergens.

Because ingredients, equipment, utensils, and preparation areas may be shared, Jenny’s Goods cannot guarantee that any product is completely free from allergens or allergen cross-contact.

Gluten-Free & Dairy-Free Options Available

Jenny’s Goods offers select gluten-free and dairy-free options upon request. However, these items may be prepared in shared environments and are not guaranteed to be free from allergen cross-contact.

Customers with food allergies, sensitivities, or dietary restrictions should inform Jenny’s Goods before placing an order. Customers with severe or life-threatening food allergies should carefully consider whether products prepared in a shared environment are appropriate for them.

By purchasing or consuming products from Jenny’s Goods, customers acknowledge the potential risks associated with food allergies and sensitivities and are responsible for making purchasing and consumption decisions based on their individual dietary needs.

Nothing in this notice is intended to waive or limit any rights or responsibilities that cannot legally be waived under applicable law.