Jenny’s Goods
Order Now

Holiday Menu

Order everything for the holidays on one page: pick your treats, choose your pickup day and time, and pay online.

  1. 1 Choose your treats
  2. 2 Your info & pickup
  3. 3 Pay

1 Choose your treats

Type how many you'd like. Everything is baked to order; choose your pickup day below.

Holiday cookies By the dozen

Caramel chocolate chunk cookies drizzled with caramel, made by Jenny’s Goods
$18.00 Buttery cookie dough loaded with chocolate chunks and swirls of caramel.
Maple pecan pie cookies topped with buttercream rosettes, made by Jenny’s Goods
$18.00 All the flavor of maple pecan pie, baked into a cookie.
Pistachio white chocolate cookies cooling on a rack, made by Jenny’s Goods
$18.00 Pistachios and creamy white chocolate in a soft, buttery cookie.
Peanut butter kiss cookies in a gift box, made by Jenny’s Goods
$18.00 A soft peanut butter cookie topped with a chocolate kiss.
Chocolate toffee cookies, made by Jenny’s Goods
$18.00 Chocolate, crunchy toffee bits and almonds in every bite.
Embossed shortbread cookies
$18.00 Light, melt-in-your-mouth whipped shortbread.

Pies 9-inch pies

Dutch apple crumb pie with pastry leaves, made by Jenny’s Goods
$20.00 Classic apple pie under a buttery Dutch crumb topping.
Thanksgiving pies from Jenny’s Goods: pumpkin, pecan and apple lattice
$20.00 Classic apple pie under a woven lattice crust.
Apple cider caramel Dutch crumb pie, made by Jenny’s Goods
$22.00 Apple pie with apple cider caramel, under a buttery Dutch crumb topping.
Apple cider caramel lattice pie with pastry leaves, made by Jenny’s Goods
$22.00 Apple pie with apple cider caramel, under a woven lattice crust.
Pumpkin pie, made by Jenny’s Goods
$20.00 Smooth, classic pumpkin pie with warm spices.
Chai pumpkin pie with a fluted crust, made by Jenny’s Goods
$20.00 Pumpkin pie with a twist of chai spices.
Maple bourbon pecan pie, made by Jenny’s Goods
$20.00 Pecan pie with maple and a splash of bourbon.
Holiday pies, New Castle, PA: homemade lattice-top cherry pie
$20.00 Sweet-tart dark cherries in a flaky crust.

Cinnamon rolls Fresh baked

Tray of fresh cinnamon rolls
$15.00 Six fresh-baked cinnamon rolls.
Jumbo cinnamon roll in a round pan
$25.00 One jumbo cinnamon roll baked in an 8-inch round. Slice and share with 12 to 15 people.

Brownies Big Back Brownies

Browned butter sea salt brownies, made by Jenny’s Goods
$18.00 Fudgy brownies made with browned butter and finished with sea salt.
Espresso Caramel Swirl brownies
$18.00 Fudgy brownies swirled with espresso caramel.
Cowboy brownies with pretzels, peanuts and whiskey ganache
$18.00 Loaded brownies with chocolate chips, pretzel pieces and peanuts, topped with whiskey ganache.
Red velvet brownies with cream cheese frosting
$18.00 Red velvet brownies topped with cream cheese frosting.
Churro blondies, made by Jenny’s Goods
$18.00 Buttery blondies with churro-style cinnamon sugar.
Matcha Luxe brownies
$18.00 Brownies made with matcha green tea.

Trays and cookie sets For sharing

Holiday cookie tray with candy cane cookies, thumbprints and lady locks
$49.00 Three dozen assorted holiday cookies, including hand-decorated cookies.
Holiday cookie tray with candy cane cookies, thumbprints and lady locks
$90.00 Six dozen assorted holiday cookies, including hand-decorated cookies. Made for parties.
Christmas cookie plate with Santa, reindeer and chocolate chip cookies
$25.00 Santa, reindeer, and cookies and milk, all hand decorated.
Grinch holiday decorated cookie set
$25.00 The Grinch, his hand with an ornament bulb, a heart, and Merry GrinchMas, all hand decorated.
Hand-decorated holiday cookie set: snowman, gingerbread, candy cane, holly and more, made by Jenny’s Goods
$25.00 Twelve cookies: snowmen, gingerbread, a snowglobe, candy cane, snowflake and holly, all hand decorated.
Hand-decorated Christmas sweater cookies, made by Jenny’s Goods
$25.00 Twelve cookies: cozy sweaters and hot cocoas, all hand decorated.
Hot cocoa mug cookies on a red plate: gingerbread, snowman, Santa, reindeer and Christmas tree
$25.00 Hot cocoa mug cookies: gingerbread, snowman, Santa, reindeer and a Christmas tree, all hand decorated.

Decorate-at-home kits Kits

Seasonal cookie decorating kit: cookies, icing and sprinkles, made by Jenny’s Goods
$25.00 A seasonal decorating kit: 6 cookies, 3 colored icing bags and 3 sprinkle bags.
Paint-your-own cookie kit with brush and edible paints, made by Jenny’s Goods
$12.00 A large cookie with a stencil, a paint brush and a paint color palette.

Want a custom cake, cupcakes or decorated cookies too? You can add a custom request after you check out.

0 items · $0.00 Next: your info & pickup ↓

2 Your info & pickup then 3 pay at the bottom

Add treats above, and this is where you'll enter your name, phone, pickup day and time, and pay.

Common Questions

Questions People Ask

How do I order from the Holiday Menu?

Choose your treats and quantities, enter your info and pickup time, then pay, all on the Holiday Menu order form.

What is on the Jenny’s Goods holiday menu?

Six holiday cookies, eight pies, cinnamon rolls, six brownies, cookie trays and sets, and two decorate-at-home kits.

© 2026 Jenny’s Goods · New Castle, PA · Privacy Policy · Terms and Conditions

Food Allergy & Safety Notice

Jenny’s Goods takes great care in preparing our baked goods, catering selections, and charcuterie offerings. However, our products are prepared in environments where common food allergens may be present.

Products may contain or come into contact with milk, eggs, wheat, peanuts, tree nuts, soy, sesame, fish, shellfish, and other allergens.

Because ingredients, equipment, utensils, and preparation areas may be shared, Jenny’s Goods cannot guarantee that any product is completely free from allergens or allergen cross-contact.

Gluten-Free & Dairy-Free Options Available

Jenny’s Goods offers select gluten-free and dairy-free options upon request. However, these items may be prepared in shared environments and are not guaranteed to be free from allergen cross-contact.

Customers with food allergies, sensitivities, or dietary restrictions should inform Jenny’s Goods before placing an order. Customers with severe or life-threatening food allergies should carefully consider whether products prepared in a shared environment are appropriate for them.

By purchasing or consuming products from Jenny’s Goods, customers acknowledge the potential risks associated with food allergies and sensitivities and are responsible for making purchasing and consumption decisions based on their individual dietary needs.

Nothing in this notice is intended to waive or limit any rights or responsibilities that cannot legally be waived under applicable law.